1
00:00:00,892 --> 00:00:03,017
Is there anything outside samsara?

2
00:00:04,079 --> 00:00:07,226
If everything has a cause, does samsara have it too?

3
00:00:08,188 --> 00:00:10,513
How does one first come into samsara?

4
00:00:11,976 --> 00:00:13,078
Three questions here.

5
00:00:13,582 --> 00:00:15,164
We'll answer them individually.

6
00:00:16,385 --> 00:00:18,388
Is there anything outside samsara?

7
00:00:18,668 --> 00:00:24,475
Samsara is a name for the conditioned universe.

8
00:00:24,976 --> 00:00:31,063
It encompasses everything that arises and therefore everything that ceases.

9
00:00:32,104 --> 00:00:36,990
It encompasses everything that is impermanent, unsatisfying, uncontrollable,

10
00:00:36,970 --> 00:00:54,050
In its briefest description, it is the five aggregates or even briefer, I suppose, is just body and mind, physical and mental aspects of experience.

11
00:00:54,070 --> 00:01:00,598
And so the word samsara, if I'm not mistaken, means wandering on, wandering, sarati,

12
00:01:01,658 --> 00:01:29,117
as I understand I can't remember the derivation but it means wandering so it's a the circle going around in circle born getting old sick and dying without any the wandering aspect this means without any goal or any resolution without getting anywhere without without actually accomplishing anything

13
00:01:29,097 --> 00:01:37,145
without any destination, most beings without any real goal, without any purpose and so on.

14
00:01:38,187 --> 00:01:48,137
But that which it is comprised of are the five aggregates or simply put body and mind, physical and mental aspects of experience.

15
00:01:48,157 --> 00:01:50,860
So is there anything outside of that?

16
00:01:51,100 --> 00:01:51,380
Yes.

17
00:01:52,281 --> 00:01:56,826
There are two things, I think you could say there are two things that are outside of that.

18
00:01:56,806 --> 00:01:59,189
One, things that don't exist.

19
00:02:01,733 --> 00:02:02,414
Concepts.

20
00:02:03,536 --> 00:02:06,921
Concepts are not a part of samsara.

21
00:02:07,041 --> 00:02:11,367
I don't think you could call them a part of samsara because they're not real.

22
00:02:11,908 --> 00:02:12,589
They don't exist.

23
00:02:13,550 --> 00:02:16,935
A concept, the chair doesn't exist.

24
00:02:17,056 --> 00:02:20,340
Monk is not something that exists.

25
00:02:21,742 --> 00:02:23,505
It's the object or it's the

26
00:02:25,105 --> 00:02:29,773
A substance of a thought, of a thought, of a recognition that arises.

27
00:02:29,813 --> 00:02:31,657
It's just a word.

28
00:02:33,200 --> 00:02:36,506
The actual chair, the actual monk doesn't exist in reality.

29
00:02:38,028 --> 00:02:43,418
So I say that would be one thing you could argue isn't a part of samsara.

30
00:02:44,613 --> 00:02:46,577
But it may be, anyway, whatever.

31
00:02:46,617 --> 00:03:02,950
More importantly, the one thing that they say that is outside of samsara because it's unconditioned, because it's satisfying, controllable, no, sorry, because it's permanent and satisfying.

32
00:03:03,031 --> 00:03:05,676
It's still uncontrollable, but it's permanent and satisfying.

33
00:03:07,242 --> 00:03:09,384
So I made a mistake there in the beginning.

34
00:03:09,484 --> 00:03:12,347
I said samsara encompasses everything that is uncontrollable.

35
00:03:12,387 --> 00:03:12,827
It doesn't.

36
00:03:13,528 --> 00:03:18,853
There's one extra thing that is uncontrollable outside of samsara.

37
00:03:19,274 --> 00:03:26,161
All dhammas including nibbana or nirvana are non-self, are uncontrollable.

38
00:03:27,642 --> 00:03:32,727
So the one thing that is really and truly outside of samsara is nibbana or nirvana.

39
00:03:34,141 --> 00:03:39,174
Because it's unconditioned, it doesn't arise, it doesn't cease, it isn't born, it doesn't die.

40
00:03:39,234 --> 00:03:44,868
It's permanent and satisfying.

41
00:03:47,374 --> 00:03:49,941
And so that's the one thing outside of samsara.

42
00:03:50,422 --> 00:03:51,745
If everything has a cause,

43
00:03:52,872 --> 00:03:56,376
So, okay, not everything has a cause because nibbana doesn't have a cause.

44
00:03:57,497 --> 00:04:00,521
And, yeah, because nibbana doesn't have a cause.

45
00:04:01,542 --> 00:04:02,944
Does samsara have a cause?

46
00:04:04,005 --> 00:04:08,430
Okay, so here's where we have to say that actually samsara doesn't exist.

47
00:04:08,491 --> 00:04:09,291
It's a concept.

48
00:04:09,532 --> 00:04:12,295
It's the name that we have for the process.

49
00:04:12,796 --> 00:04:16,820
But the process is actually made up of building blocks and those building blocks actually exist.

50
00:04:17,261 --> 00:04:18,823
Those are the things that have causes.

51
00:04:20,104 --> 00:04:22,407
So I think you could say concepts...

52
00:04:24,361 --> 00:04:31,580
technically speaking, don't have a cause because by the word cause you mean something that causes it to arise and concepts do not arise.

53
00:04:31,600 --> 00:04:33,425
A concept is something that doesn't exist.

54
00:04:35,430 --> 00:04:39,180
It's an illusion.

55
00:04:41,388 --> 00:04:44,213
Or you could say it exists but not in ultimate reality.

56
00:04:44,914 --> 00:04:52,668
So it has a cause in a conventional sense, but in reality is uncaused, I would think.

57
00:04:52,848 --> 00:05:02,805
These are all technical words and I'm probably saying, probably the technical answer is a bit different, but there is a distinction to be made.

58
00:05:02,785 --> 00:05:10,978
So when you conflate these, and you don't make this distinction, you start to say, well, everything has a cause.

59
00:05:11,158 --> 00:05:14,544
The samsara have as well, and you're talking about two different things.

60
00:05:14,624 --> 00:05:23,297
In Buddhism, those things that have a cause are the five aggregates, the physical and mental aspects of experience.

61
00:05:23,337 --> 00:05:26,262
They are causally formed.

62
00:05:27,912 --> 00:05:29,294
And so that's what we focus on.

63
00:05:29,314 --> 00:05:32,459
Now samsara is just a name for all of that.

64
00:05:34,723 --> 00:05:38,489
So the third question, how does one first come into samsara?

65
00:05:38,509 --> 00:05:46,923
The implication is that it has a cause, there was something before it, which is one of those questions not answered in Buddhism.

66
00:05:47,844 --> 00:05:53,413
And you can disregard it simply because it's meaningless, purposeless, it's in the past.

67
00:05:53,393 --> 00:06:16,498
But it seems also to be potentially unanswerable or improper as a question, because it relies on the idea that time is linear, the idea that the past actually somehow exists, or the idea that the past is the cause of everything and so on.

68
00:06:16,478 --> 00:06:20,364
In Buddhism we don't start with the past, we start with the present.

69
00:06:21,045 --> 00:06:25,812
And the present is creating the past and bringing about the future.

70
00:06:26,733 --> 00:06:32,662
But we take the present as our base, kind of like ripples in a pool of water.

71
00:06:32,842 --> 00:06:36,748
Everything, the past and the future, expand out from the present moment.

72
00:06:36,728 --> 00:06:59,496
which actually may be supported somehow by things like quantum physics, which seems to suggest that the future can actually affect the past or seems to, not suggest, but has the potential to show, one of the answers is to show that the future can actually affect the past, which is really strange.

73
00:06:59,476 --> 00:07:04,303
but would explain the ability to predict the future, see the future and that kind of thing.

74
00:07:05,625 --> 00:07:19,003
Anyway, one of the questions that the Buddha declined to answer is the idea of something, how one came into, what was before samsara or so on.